A short Catholic critique of secular libertarianism

Originally posted: November 10, 2026 / Last modified: November 10, 2026

As demonstrated in 1 Corinthians 12:12, the Church is fundamentally a spiritual community of believers beyond any and all earthly distinctions of race, sex, age, disability, or national origin. For this same reason our Church is “universal” as everyone is a spiritual equal before God and has equal chances to enter the faith.

The medieval ideal was the res publica Christiana as an objective spiritual ideal. This is the purpose that private government is made to fulfill, a Christian social order governed by Christian men and Christian princes. It makes necessary distinctions between Christians and non-Christians without any necessary disrespect for the latter, and puts the former under the wing of a Christian society under a Christian moral order, under the spiritual jurisdiction of the Church. The Middle Ages is often described as a “theocracy” but the reality is that it was based on a variable degree of legal pluralism i.e. the Church was a private jurisdiction under law (“corporation”) that welded influence over the nobility (including the king), which didn’t necessarily apply to religious foreigners.

In my own view, I would qualify most of the medieval era as a “republic” meant in the proper sense of a civilization dedicated to community and public office, or “duty” & “obligation”, but on the other side, many modern republics only projecting private interests.

On the other hand, the kingdom, resting on a thick web of relations dependent on honor and fealty, is naturally the best steward of virtue. A republic can only dissolve, when a monarchy always builds. Public here can be taken to mean, “not equal”, or constructive. People in a Christian social order enter their natural ranks and work in their natural roles to maintain the res publica and ensure its prosperity.

Some people conceive that integralists and libertarians must be completely opposed in overall politics and visions. I do not think this is true. Christian conservatives also provided a intuitive lesson for those with libertarian views. Frank van Dun and Paul Kogos came to realize the same thing. 9 times out of 10, principled libertarians are going to find themselves on the side of inherited conservative institutions when defending liberty in practice. Burke, a Whig, realized precisely this. So did many other liberals of the time. It is also notable that Mr. Hoppe spoke of the “praxeological compatibility” of libertarianism and conservatism, that is to say, traditionalist conservatism.

A private law society must be grounded in natural law and natural rights, and as Hoppe notes, it should eventually come towards a unification of legal norms. If we consider libertarianism itself to be a philosophy, it can not be envisioned to be a mostly atheistic or even “secular” society. Atheism produces “philosophy”, the free competition of worldviews. Libertarianism can house believers in any philosophy but some philosophies cannot accommodate libertarianism and even seek to destroy it. Marxism itself is a philosophy, and Rousseau was also a philosopher. In order for law to unify, it is necessary for the cooperation of civil society under one cosmic worldview, to the lesser inclusion of approximates like liberals or general Abrahamic religions (Islam, Judaism, etc.)

To see what I mean here, I’ll provide a contrast. In the Middle Ages, theology was considered to be “the queen of all sciences” and as such they could only develop in dialogue with it. Noticeably, however, we also notice that libertarianism in large part developed from the Thomistic worldview of this. Rothbard’s theory of natural law itself has secular Thomist underpinnings, but the connections run much earlier than Rothbard. It seems natural then, that in order to secure a libertarian social order, theology must become “the queen of all sciences” again and that the Church regain its spiritual jurisdiction over “civil society” and “private government”. Grounded in a transcendent moral order that maintains that not one earthly being is above God, a consistent morality and culture can be produced that firmly upholds the rule of law necessary for a liberal society.

The Catholic Church has always been a corporate jurisdiction that even still preaches “subsidiarity” and warns of the dangers of statolatry. For this reason, statists everywhere and every time throughout history have condemned the Church has a threat to “national sovereignty”. The concept of a “national Church” like that of Russia is foreign to the subjects of Rome. The Church always intended itself as the institutions who legitimates princes and one that imposes deliberate moral limits on them.

Not only Christian libertarians but also the old reactionaries were acutely aware of this. In his Speech on Dictatorship, Donoso described two different types of repression which he saw as necessary for the survival and maintenance of civilization, that is, political and religious. These two forms of repression must exist in an equilibrium in order to be effective. With a decline in religious repression must come a corresponding and proportional rise in political repression, and vice versa. As the thermometer of religious repression falls, the thermometer of political repression must rise; and as the thermometer of political repression falls, so the thermometer of religious repression must rise. All political and religious régimes must respectively be repressive if political and religious order are to endure.

This lesson doesn’t just apply to Christianity too but all stateless societies in general. I’ve explained this before. In the anthropological books and essays that I have read, their social norms and law always have superstitious foundations. It’s the idea of cosmic balance which limited ancient rulers and curbed the greed of hunter-gatherers living under immediate-return conditions. The revolutionary aspect about Christianity however is its idea of spiritual equality. The supply of legitimacy that all statists need is cut off as each and everyone is equally affected by the Fall and is always prone to sin. In contrast, many ancient rulers considered themselves gods or their representatives. No such thing exists under a Catholic order nor can it be allowed to. It is notable that this doctrine only genuinely returned after the Reformation, usually either under the veil of sovereign Protestant denominations or Church localization. While divine right generally underpinned all Christian monarchies of the Middle Ages, it did not exist in the sense that pop-history conceives of it until the Reformation provided the means to legitimate it.


Leave a Reply

© 2026 Fukis.jp