The privatisation myth debunked

Originally posted: October 30, 2026 / Last modified: October 30, 2026

Much that is called “privatisation” is really the granting of state privileges to nominally private firms.

Socialists hate the claim that the National Socialists were Socialists. I don’t care to state my position on this claim itself; it has some truth, but also some non-truths. Either way, the incorrect pivot is when they go to state that the National Socialists were apparently free-market capitalists, to a degree that (which I have yet to see a source for) that they were also the original regime that provoked the coining of the phrase “privatisation”, which meant something else back then and wouldn’t matter anyway since plenty of privatisations happened before the Reich. I’ve also seen some neo-Nazis of the Rockwellian variety (Rockwell was very open about being for “free enterprise”, due to the conditions of America under McCarthyism) say this as well. Both are incorrect.

I’ll go ahead and quote Against the Mainstream: Nazi Privatization in 1930s Germany, which is an article they love to use, like a lot.

It seems clear that neither the Nazi Party nor Hitler had any ideological devotion to private ownership. In their theoretical work on the relationship between politicians and firms, Shleifer and Vishny (1994, p. 1,015) stress that anti-market governments are compatible with privatization, as long as they can retain control over the firms through strong regulation. Nazi privatization in the mid-1930s is consistent with Shleifer and Vishny’s proposition 15 (1994, p. 1,021). As suggested in Temin (1991), property ownership was instrumental for the Nazis. Hence, it is not likely that ideological motivations played a major role as a rationale for Nazi privatization. It is likely that privatization – as a policy favorable to private property – was used as a tool for fostering the alliance between Nazi government and industrialists. The government sought to win support for its policies from big business, even though most industrialists had been reluctant to support the Nazi party before it took power. Although modern economic literature usually ignores the fact, the Nazi government in 1930s Germany undertook a wide scale privatization policy. The government sold public ownership in several State-owned firms in different sectors. In addition, delivery of some public services previously produced by the public sector was transferred to the private sector, mainly to organizations within the Nazi Party.

While there was a time where the Reich was involved with a liberal economist (Scacht), it’s questionable whether he actually implemented liberalisations. Under him and his advice, the government exploited MEFO bills and did massive property expropriations. His economics aimed to aid with rapid militarisation more than anything. The actual economist of National Socialism was Gottfried Feder, and many of his proposals never genuinely came to light, although he had economic views just as dumb as the rest of the NSDAP did.

So what the hell is going on here? It’s incredibly simple. The National Socialists aimed to use privatisation as a tool of Gleichschaltung. Basically, the National Socialists strategically subordinated economics to political interests, utilising liberalisations and planning where possible, but their ultimate goal was a “socialist” economy, an economy where economic affairs were entirely coordinated by the state; while property rights would be nominally preserved, it was entirely subordinate to the plan and economic dictates set out by the party, and rights could be easily manipulated by the state as they pleased. The National Socialists saw property rights as a fidicuary relationship that should be used to “the benefit of the people’s community”. The state reserved the right to take away the property of those who they saw as misusing their rights.

The National Socialist system shouldn’t be confused with the Fascist system of corporatism, although they outwardly look similar. In Fascist corporatism, while the unions are state-owned, it aims to incorporate class interests into the direct body of the state, used as a tool for negotiating their respective interests. In the end, the classes are supposed to govern themselves and work out their own respective conflicts of interests. National Socialism, however, doesn’t seek to do this. It seeks to dissolve class entirely. While the workplace hierarchy is preserved, production is supposed to be entirely dictated in cooperation with the state. That was the actual purpose of the German Labour Front, other than generating a working-class support base. Furthermore, as the National Socialists held on to “traditional Germanic values” of fealty, absolute loyalty to employers was prioritised over all else, and the workplace was conceptualised as a sort of fief that managed the resources of the people’s community. In contrast, in the Fascist model, open State or partisan violence was welcomed towards employers who didn’t cooperate. They (including the syndicalist Fascists) didn’t seem to think that contradicted their ban on striking, so long as the economy was seen to be productive.

This part from Kevin Carson explains it quite well.

Neumann and the rest of the Frankfurt School described, as the aim of fascism, to transcend the internal contradictions of capitalism, in much the same way that Immanuel Wallerstein argued the feudal ruling class transcended the internal contradictions of feudalism. According to Wallerstein, a subgroup of the feudal ruling class reconfigured themselves as agrarian capitalists, and negotiated the transition to capitalism, setting themselves up as the core of the new ruling class over a new social system. Similarly, Wallerstein speculates, a section of the capitalist ruling class may attempt to survive the collapse of corporate capitalism from its internal contradictions, by setting themselves up as the ruling class of a post-market collectivist society. That’s exactly what fascism attempted to do, according to the Frankfurt School: to create a post-capitalist, or at least post-market, society under the control of the biggest finance capitalists. The capitalists, in the Frankfurt School scenario, attempt to transcend the law of value and mediate an increasing share of economic transactions directly through the state rather than the market price system.

The National Socialist economy was actually far more anti-market than even the planned corporatist economy of today’s China, which is still nonetheless considered “socialist”, while the National Socialists were considered to be duping the working-class with their claim to “socialism”. While the preservation of class divides and private enterprise necessarily demanded the preservation of the value-form — in the Reich, the economy could be considered “bureaucracy with markets at the margins” — it was ultimately intending to supersede value altogether, and turn the economy wholly into state-directed production for use. It wouldn’t have been very dissimilar from the USSR, and that was indeed Hitler’s later goal. The centralisation of agriculture and the prevalence of forced labour amongst the Reich also make sense in this context. Most empires and colonies resort to market economies or market slave economies, and that makes sense, because empires often aim to continuously generate capital and wealth. The National Socialists, however, opted for state-directed slavery, because it was the easiest way to eliminate the mediation of price signals from direct capital production. And while they did engage in exchange with the products of this labour to some degree, it’s also true that they often tried to avoid doing this, and if they merely aimed to generate capital and wealth, why would they immediately pivoted to enslaving populations for no gain but the state? Hitler himself said,

Of what importance is all that, if I range men firmly within a discipline they cannot escape? Let them own land or factories as much as they please. The decisive factor is that the State, through the Party, is supreme over them regardless of whether they are owners or workers. All that is unessential; our socialism goes far deeper. It establishes a relationship of the individual to the State, the national community. Why need we trouble to socialize banks and factories? We socialize human beings.

The last part indicates, too, that Hitler saw essentially no seperation between ‘nation’ and ‘state’. Service to the Party is service to the state; service to the State is service to the Volkgemeinschaft. The Fascists in Italy didn’t see any such distinction either. Because the ‘state’ is intended to be the organic governance of the whole of the ‘national community’, Mussolini had even gone so far as to say that the anarchist goals of those like Malatesta were fulfilled, for the old State that was an enemy of the original liberals had disappeared.


Leave a Reply

© 2026 Fukis.jp